[Re-Post] Poll: Shea Weber or Rick Nash? July 6th, 2012 9:25 am @AdamRotter Need to run a poll – Weber, or Nash. I’d rather give up assets for Weber. — Lou Monte Jr (@LouMonte) July 4, 2012 Take Our Poll Like this:Like Loading... 157 comments   Get Livefyre FAQ Sign in + Follow Post comment Link Newest | Oldest Eric Dixon 5pts devito tho... Eric Dixon 5pts nah marcus81 5pts off course they should NOT have let him go, he replaced Faneca and the Line was still good with him there, he could have been signed long term for very reasonable money chuco 5pts Man he can walk we have lots of salary cap here comes our spree j.e.t.s James Plath 5pts He had to go - his beard wasn't up to Mangold standards. McGeorge 5pts I thought it was a mistake at the time to let Slauson go.Tannenbaums wasting a 2nd round pick on a reach (Ducass) hurt a lot when that could have been used on a receiver.Passing wins games, not ground and pound. Pass blocking is important, and had the Jets had Slausson this year Geno wouldn't have been pressured as much. Its not impossible the Jets would have won one more game and made the playoffs. Not saying it's likely but it would have helped. privatejet 5pts Whateves ... time to move on. I say bring in Incognito so he can mentor Ducasse and Winters. djf1 5pts He looks like he should be in a black metal band. jaym 5pts The same thing will happen with Ducasse BILLY 5pts Can't blame the Jets for letting Slauson go. It seemed like Matt may have been breaking down physically. With that having been said, in retrospect, yeah, it would have been great to keep him. But who would have known? Now, I do blame Idzik (or Rex) for stubbornly keeping Winters in the starting lineup. Brian Miros 5pts Keeping VLAD "King Ugly" Duccase over Slauson was a mistake johnnyl65 5pts @McGeorge ""Passing wins games, not ground and pound" And yet we got to two AFC championships with ground and pound and defense. Go figure. Brendan 5pts @privatejet It's just not the same when Butters isn't saying it. here2win 5pts If you look at the players drafted in between K.Wilson and V. Ducasse, you'd have to say the Jets scouting staff might have been asleep at the wheel. Lets hope Idzik's guys make us forget about guys like Slauson and Ducasse in short order the OLine depth isn't a thing of beauty.The Draft offers some good guys and Zane Beadles is the top free agent. While I like W. Colon his recent injury might leave him off the 2014 roster. johnnyl65 5pts @jaym Sad,but probably true. Brendan 5pts @jaym I'm genuinely concerned this will happen. McGeorge 5pts @BILLY I don't agree. I do blame the Jets for letting him go. He is ok and teams need average players to fill out the roster. Brendan 5pts @Brian Miros Vlad outplayed Slauson last year, though. Brendan 5pts @johnnyl65 @McGeorge And the two teams playing in the Super Bowl last year were both teams that ran it very well and didn't have exceptional passing attacks. djf1 5pts @Brendan @privatejet I miss my beer mug. And a readable username. Still don't feel like going the fake twitter route though. djf1 5pts @Brendan @jaym If they let him go as I assume they will, that likely leaves us without a decent experienced backup G. bradysucks 5pts @Brendan@Brian Miros Enough about Vlad, Gates, Hill and the rest of team SCRUBTime to cut them loose on a row boat out to sea captained by Admiral Buttfumble Wolf 5pts Slauson was injured, though. bradysucks 5pts @Bent@bradysucks In Denver there were 9 men in the box and Tebow's ultra accurate arm throwing Decker beautiful spirals..... :) .......Funny how having Tebow in NY is a nightmare for the WR's but in Denver playing with Tebow only helped Decker be a productive WR ....really?C'mon now.....Decker is a big upgrade over Stephen Hill. I'm here for you Bent. It's okay to like offense and scoring......really it is. The more points the Jets score the happier those guys you love on defense will be, bradysucks 5pts @a57se@bradysucks Idzik already said in one his interviews on the Jets team website that he plans to bring in some new faces on offense....I can't imagine Idzik not signing at least one free agent WR and drafting a WR in either round 1 or round 2. Idzik isn't stupid. He knows the Jets have a good defense and had difficulty scoring points.Everybody knows this...... a57se 5pts @bradysucks If we don't draft any WR's in the first three rounds, Idzik should be fired. bradysucks 5pts @Brendan@bradysucks I think Hill should get a tryout. I don't believe in throwing away lottery tickets. I wouldn't just give him the 5th receiver spot though. If Idzik goes through the 2014 draft and free agency and determines that of all of the WR's on planet earth that Stephen Hill is the best available WR option for the Jets - then fine Brendan 5pts @bradysucks @Brendan I'd take him as a #5 receiver if that means the Jets beat the Billdos every year. bradysucks 5pts @Brendan@bradysucks Well if I was the GM we would have never drafted Sanchez or Stephen Hill.....Hey I get why people like Stephen Hill......but I haven't seen anything from him in 2 years except when the Jets play the Bills......People make fun of me for liking Jordan White (who was chronically injured) and the same people defend Hill (and use chronic injuries as an excuse).The Jets have had an unwatchable passing offense since 2011.....It is time for change...BIG CHANGE. Brendan 5pts @bradysucks Good thing you're not the GM. bradysucks 5pts @djf1@bradysucks Right now we have 2 WR's on our roster who deserve to be on the team next year1) Kerley2) NelsonEvery other guy should be replaced djf1 5pts @bradysucks Forget Gates. I'm still hopeful for Hill, but he has to be the #4 or #5, and work his way up if he can. We need two good receivers to complement Kerley - one FA and one high draft pick would be nice. bradysucks 5pts @Brendan@bradysucks I don't get married to players....Decker would be nice...but I understand it has to make financial sense.....I hope the Jets take advantage of free agency....I am not a believer in Gates and Hill.......They are both sports cars that break down all the time and give the Jets bad gas mileage.....The Jets need to find some reliable WR's......There are plenty of them out there who have much better ball skills, and route running ability than Gates/Hill.......There are guys out there who catch the football..... Brendan 5pts @bradysucks If Eric Decker wants a premier NFL WR contract (5 years, $55m+), you would give it to him? bradysucks 5pts @Brendan@bradysucks I was being sarcastic....I'll stop making fun of Hill if it bothers you..... djf1 5pts @Brendan @bradysucks @Bent I was going to make a joke by using a different Decker, but Eric is the only Decker in the NFL history, apparently. So I'll just do the other option:Hill > Decker.Drew Hill, that is. bradysucks 5pts @johnnyl65@Brendan@bradysucks@Bent My suggestion is we draft either a top WR or top QB in round 1 of the draft and take advantage of free agency and yes that includes Decker Brendan 5pts @bradysucks This is the BS people disliked, bud. Just ignore relevant comments and continue repeating yourself. You had such a good run going, come on back to the light side. johnnyl65 5pts @Brendan @bradysucks @Bent Also no one other than BS would suggest we sign Decker to be our #1. bradysucks 5pts @Brendan@bradysucks@Bent Hollywood just cast Stephen Hill in the next Invisible Man movie. Rumour has it he didn't even have to audition. They knew he was "perfect" for the role. Okay....enough about HillWe all know the Jets need some new receivers.....I am sure Idzik will keep Tannenbaum's lottery ticket (aka Hill) next year Brendan 5pts @bradysucks @Bent Oh, good, the old BS has returned. No one, repeat: NO ONE, is saying Hill > Decker. bradysucks 5pts @Bent@bradysucks Decker > HillWhere does Decker rank in production compared to his NFL WR peers......Where does Hill Rank?Sadly Hill is awake only one game each season....and that is when the Jets play the Bills.....The rest of the time he is in a coma Brendan 5pts @bradysucks Only because of the volume of throws he saw. Decker's 96 targets that year is only 9 less than Hill has had in his entire career. Bent 5pts @bradysucks What a fallacy that is. His numbers with Tebow were good because there were nine men in the box so he had single coverage whenever Tebow actually decided to throw it.Daniel Fells had 256 yards and 3TDs with Tebow but then went to NE and caught four passes and now he's out of the league. johnnyl65 5pts @bradysucks I knew you were a robot with those automated responses. a57se 5pts @Brendan@bradysucks Look at all the TD's he has scored!!! Plus he drinks Brawny! This is the same guy who wanted Jordan White to start because he caught over 100 balls in college....production, no matter the reason is all BS sees.There is some merit to that view, FWIW! bradysucks 5pts @Brendan@bradysucks Decker's numbers and production playing on a team with Tebow, an awesome QB, were still better than Stephen Hill'sBazinga Brendan 5pts @bradysucks @Brendan How much Decker have you watched? He is not known for route running, he is a tall, vertical threat. a57se 5pts @bradysucks@a57se You are the master of hindsight. bradysucks 5pts @Brendan@bradysucks I'll take a 6 foot 4 inch Decker who can catch and run routes over a 6 foot 4 inch Hill who does neither well.You can take your road trip in a fancy spots car that breaks down all the time and has crappy gas mileage. I'll take a new Honda Accord on a long distance road trip with a smile on my face here2win 5pts @bradysucksBassett will be writing one of these same "shoulda Kept" Hill post next year. I think the team should keep Hill around and let him develop in Marty's system and see what he looks like a year from now. He looked very good after training camp and made some strides but I think that Pittsburgh game early in the year really hurt his confidence. Brendan 5pts @bradysucks @Brendan Eric Decker, the guy created by Peyton and who is going to want #1 WR money? Passssssss. bradysucks 5pts @a57se@bradysucks Keenan Allen, Alshon Jeffery etc....While I get your point the fact is that the Jets passed on guys who were big time producers in high school and college in favor of a WR who wasn't recruited highly out of high school and had next to zero production in college. Hill was overdrafted. You don't waste a second round pick on a guy who takes 4 to 5 years to develop if he develops at all (see Vlad Ducasse) a57se 5pts @bradysucks@Brendan That is not how you build a winning team in the NFL....Your Yankee fandom is showing. bradysucks 5pts @Brendan@bradysucks Sign me up for Eric Decker, a new WR in the 1st or 2nd round, Nelson, Kerley, and possibly another free agent WR......all of whom are better options than Stephen HillGive Hill a tryout with the team....nothing more a57se 5pts @bradysucks What draft pick isn't a lottery ticket? Brendan 5pts @bradysucks Hill has been hurt for two seasons. You don't write him off. You've never liked him, and I'm sure you'll throw a little party if/when he's cut, but that time is not in the offseason before his 3rd season. bradysucks 5pts @Brendan@bradysucks He sucks.....Can't catch, can't stay healthy, can't run routes......He's a lottery ticket.....Submitting a business plan where you plan to pay your rent by buying a lottery ticket is a crappy idea......Hill has had no production...... a57se 5pts @Brendan@bradysucks Yeah and if you don't cut a 23 year old WR, you certainly don't cut hill who is only 22! johnnyl65 5pts @Brendan @bradysucks Still on a rookie deal. Brendan 5pts @bradysucks You don't cut a 23 year old WR who was a 3-4 year project out of the draft before his 3rd year. Wolf 5pts I wish I could respond to you both but I think we reached max lifefyre discussion capacity. Brendan 5pts @Wolf When a guy is hurt every year, that's not a legitimate negative? Bent 5pts @Wolf For the third straight season...which probably factored into their decision not to overpay for him.